The interesting history of the Broad Street water fountain

July 18, 2014 chris
Share on FacebookShare on Google+Tweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

Have you ever wondered about the little marble water fountain on Broad Street near the Emma Sansom statue and in front of Gadsden City Hall? 

Recently on the “Welcome to Gadsden” Facebook page, a photo was shown of the old fountain, and folks began asking about it. The Vagabond did research on this subject and found it had a very interesting history, including a movement that was a part of the history of the United States.

It all started back in many towns of Ohio and New York in the fall of 1873. Women who were concerned about the destructive power of alcohol met in churches to pray and then marched to the saloons to ask the owners to close their establishments.

After listening to a lecture by Dr. Dio Lewis, groups initially were moved to a non-violent protest against the dangers of alcohol. Normally quiet housewives dropped to their knees in pray-ins in local saloons and demanded that the sale of liquor be stopped. In three months, the women had driven liquor out of 250 communities and for the first time felt what could be accomplished by standing together.

The movement met with success but it was only temporary. By the next summer, the women concluded that they must become organized nationally. This led to the founding of the National Woman’s Christian Temperance Union – the oldest continuing non-sectarian woman’s organization in the world.

In the great temperance crusade of 1874, a National Convention was called to meet in Cleveland, Ohio on Nov. 17, at which 16   states were represented and the NWCTU organization formed. By 1916, every state and territory in the nation was organized. Conditions of membership were signing the total abstinence pledge and paying annually into the treasury of the local union a sum of not less than 50 cents. Part of the money was retained for local work, and a part was used for auxiliary offices, state, national and world needs. The total paid membership in the United States in 1919 was about a half million. The badge of the society was a bow of white ribbon.

At the 1874 organizing convention of the National Woman’s Christian Temperance Union, the members were urged to erect drinking fountains in their towns so that men could get a drink of water without entering saloons and staying for stronger drinks. The drinking fountains that were erected often offered a place for horses to drink, another place for dogs, and of course, a place for humans to drink.

Like many women in small Southern communities, the women of Gadsden, Alabama, knew nothing of the existence of the W.C.T.U. In a local newspaper, Marietta Sibert (the mother of Gadsden’s William Sibert of the Panama Canal fame) contacted the National Union, which sent member Sally Chapin to affiliate the group with the N.W.C.T.U. Marietta died in 1909 and never got to see the final results in this area.

In 1880, a number of citizens of Gadsden and Etowah County petitioned the state legislature for a local option for the county, which aroused an interest in the subject of temperance. 

In May 1882, a small local union was organized with Mrs. L. C. Woodliff, president, and fourteen charter members. 

In December of 1883, the women of Tuscaloosa organized a local union under the name of “Woman’s Home Union.”

In January 1884, a state meeting was held in Tuscaloosa. Besides representatives of the unions from Selma, Gadsden, and Tuscaloosa, national officers Mrs. Sallie Chapin of Charleston, S.C., and Miss Henrietta Moore, of Ohio, were present. At that convention, the State Union was organized, with Mrs. L. C. Woodliff of Gadsden as the first president and Mrs. Charles Sibert of Gadsden as secretary.

In October 1884, Mrs. Woodliff attended the 11th National Convention of the W. C. T. U., which was held at St. Louis, Mo. In November of that year, the second annual Convention of the Alabama Union was held at Selma, to which Mrs. Woodliff brought great inspiration in her report of the proceedings of the National Convention she had recently attended. The third annual State Convention was held at Birmingham in November, 1885, at which time a Mrs. Bryce was president.

By November 1907, Alabama Governor B.B. Comer called a special session on the relation of the railways to the state. An opportunity was seized to press statewide prohibition, and there was no difficulty in getting the two-thirds vote required.

One Alabama newspaper reported, “Alabama is soon to become one of the dry states.” 

In 1908, the legislature enacted a state prohibitory law, to take effect January 1, 1909. Local option had previously driven the saloons out of 50 of the state’s 67 counties. At the last previous session of the legislature, laws were enacted giving county local option and preventing shipment of liquor from wet territory to dry.”

Another newspaper reported, “Our larger towns, Birmingham, Decatur, Gadsden, Huntsville and Dothan under prohibition, have greatly decreased their criminal record. We estimate that with a few years of prohibition, our penitentiaries will show a marked decrease in the number of their inmates.”

Even later another paper stated, “Reports are uniform that there is less drunkenness and less crime. In many counties, the jails are practically em-pty. In several cities the police force has been reduced. Many croons most pathetically, with strange intonation, ‘Old Booze is dead.’ 

The Chief of Police of Birmingham reported a decrease in crime and improvement in public order. The State Superintendent of the Anti-Saloon League estimated that general crime has been reduced more than 60 percent and drunkenness 85 percent. The judge of the Criminal Court of Gadsden said the influence, which led to the passage of the law, was “good women and bad whisky.”

Prior to all this, we already found that Mrs. A.L. Woodliff was already president of the Alabama Women’s Christian Union, the first president of the organization in the state, and that the group in Gadsden was the second to be organized in the State.

Gadsden soon found out that a law not backed by public sentiment meant but little. It was at this time that the Women’s Christian Temperance Union took root in the city, led by such women as Mrs. Woodliff, Mrs. Barrett and Mrs. Stevenson, who never knew defeat, and never gave up the fight, even when it seemed that the cause was lost.

Mrs. Woodliff had known Carrie Nation as well as Dr. Anna Shaw. She found them inspiring, and her own belief and work were founded upon what she personally believed to be right, and this was true of Mrs. Barrett and Mrs. Stevenson, although Mrs. Stevenson was not an advocate of “votes for women.”

She was just as firm against woman suffrage as she was against liquor, and simply could not see that giving women the vote would change anything. This difference in opinion never effected her friendship for the other two ladies of our story, who went on talking to their friends on the subject of suffrage even as they worked for prohibition.

A 1914 editorial from a local publication was made, stating that, “Too much credit cannot be given the members of the Gadsden W.C.T.U. for the efficient work they have accomplished in making of Gadsden one of the cleanest and most moral cities in the state. Gadsden and Etowah County are held up as examples throughout the state…We are glad that the visiting members can see for themselves that this claim is not unfounded.”

In another article in the same paper, we read, “The members of the local organization today pointed Gadsden out as a model prohibition city and they were given a practical illustration of what can be accomplished where men of honor are put into office to enforce the laws.” 

The work of these ladies caused all the saloons to close down in Gadsden, as well as causing the Spoon Motlow (Jack Daniel) Distillery Plant on Tuscaloosa Avenue to shut down. 

The article also read,  “Women have not stood solidly for those better things for which such women as Laura Barrett, Chester Woodliff and Florence Stevenson worked and prayed – but let us thank God for the work and the prayers, and the dreams…Without them we should have lost the hope for better things, which still is ours, and the means to bring these things about which is in our hands, if we will only use it.”

So there you have it, the history of the little marble fountain in the front of Gadsden City Hall. The fountains erected by local WCTU Unions throughout the U.S. are still in existence – some still giving water, and a number have been restored within the last few years. A few remain in their original location, but many have been moved to parks or other public spaces.

It would be nice if our city fathers would repair this fountain and turn the water back on.